DOMINICI.COM

DOMINICI Forums => General Discussion => Topic started by: xoxoch on April 24, 2008, 12:22:34 PM



Title: question for matt
Post by: xoxoch on April 24, 2008, 12:22:34 PM
I have an english grammar question:

which one is correct:

what band do you like?
which band do you like?

*confused*

is there a rule for that?


ps. of course, everyone's invited to provide help  :)


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: Matt Gillis on April 24, 2008, 01:18:19 PM
Well, just off the top of my head:

"what band do you like?" is good for in general, only it sounds peculiar with the singular subject. So to make it sound more "normal" i'd say "what bands do you like?" and that would be a little more valid, even if it does change the meaning a bit (by making the subject plural, you are asking them if they like more than just one band).

"which band do you like?" would be what you'd use in the specific case. For example, if you ask someone while in the line for a show "which band do you like?" your implying a comparrison to something with the word "which", so they can infer that you are asking which band they like that is playing at the show. You did the exact same "comparrison" when you asked me the question: "which one is correct?" -- you provided me with two statements and asked which was "more" gramatically correct. So when using the "which band do you like?", I'd use it in specific cases, where there is only a limited amount of bands to choose from, where they are in comparrison to one another.

With the second case though, it might be better to add a modifer on the end, like "best". It just makes the meaning a little clearer. "Which band do you like best?" when comparing bands for example.


So in general, to save you all the fancy talk:

What: This is what you say when trying to aquire information. i.e. "What is the date today?", "What is your favorite band?", etc.

Which: This is used to ask for information  specifying one or more people or things from a set. "Which pair of shoes do you like better?", "Which band had the better drummer?", etc. 

Hope this helps  :blob:

And anyone can put in additional imput if you like, I'm sure I missed something somewhere  :lol


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: VFS on April 24, 2008, 01:57:52 PM
your implying a comparrison

And anyone can put in additional imput if you like, I'm sure I missed something somewhere  :lol

you're
comparison (only one "r")
iNput (not iMput)

:blob:

your summary is beautiful, though. :tup


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: xoxoch on April 25, 2008, 06:39:53 AM
brilliant thanks... I always used what/which by gut feeling - dude, you're a genius! you deciphered my guts  :metal


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: VFS on April 25, 2008, 10:54:35 AM
dude, you're a genius! you deciphered my guts  :metal

Matt's signature should make room for that quote :lol :metal


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: Matt Gillis on April 25, 2008, 05:11:56 PM
 :lol

Uhh, thanks?  :lol


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: Matt Gillis on April 26, 2008, 08:56:54 AM
your implying a comparrison

And anyone can put in additional imput if you like, I'm sure I missed something somewhere  :lol

you're
comparison (only one "r")
iNput (not iMput)

:blob:

your summary is beautiful, though. :tup


Yeah, asides from the "your" (I let that one slip  :d'oh: ) the other two were typos. I don't feel too bad when I put "m" instead of "n" in a word though, but typos can be REALLY bad. For example: One year, I was learning about "the great vowel shift" in English. I quickly realized that whoever was teaching it, or if you were typing it, etc. you had to be VERY careful when typing "v"owel, since we all know what other letter is beside "v" on our North American keyboards. . .

Thankfully, I never screwed that up  :lol


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: xoxoch on April 26, 2008, 10:28:59 AM
your implying a comparrison

And anyone can put in additional imput if you like, I'm sure I missed something somewhere  :lol

you're
comparison (only one "r")
iNput (not iMput)

:blob:

your summary is beautiful, though. :tup


Yeah, asides from the "your" (I let that one slip  :d'oh: ) the other two were typos. I don't feel too bad when I put "m" instead of "n" in a word though, but typos can be REALLY bad. For example: One year, I was learning about "the great vowel shift" in English. I quickly realized that whoever was teaching it, or if you were typing it, etc. you had to be VERY careful when typing "v"owel, since we all know what other letter is beside "v" on our North American keyboards. . .

Thankfully, I never screwed that up  :lol

 :rollin

apparently european keyboards have the same letter next to "v"  :rollin


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: charliedominici on April 26, 2008, 04:53:09 PM
Well, just off the top of my head:

"what band do you like?" is good for in general, only it sounds peculiar with the singular subject. So to make it sound more "normal" i'd say "what bands do you like?" and that would be a little more valid, even if it does change the meaning a bit (by making the subject plural, you are asking them if they like more than just one band).

"which band do you like?" would be what you'd use in the specific case. For example, if you ask someone while in the line for a show "which band do you like?" your implying a comparrison to something with the word "which", so they can infer that you are asking which band they like that is playing at the show. You did the exact same "comparrison" when you asked me the question: "which one is correct?" -- you provided me with two statements and asked which was "more" gramatically correct. So when using the "which band do you like?", I'd use it in specific cases, where there is only a limited amount of bands to choose from, where they are in comparrison to one another.

With the second case though, it might be better to add a modifer on the end, like "best". It just makes the meaning a little clearer. "Which band do you like best?" when comparing bands for example.


So in general, to save you all the fancy talk:

What: This is what you say when trying to aquire information. i.e. "What is the date today?", "What is your favorite band?", etc.

Which: This is used to ask for information  specifying one or more people or things from a set. "Which pair of shoes do you like better?", "Which band had the better drummer?", etc. 

Hope this helps  :blob:

And anyone can put in additional imput if you like, I'm sure I missed something somewhere  :lol
Plus there is a huge difference between:
"What the fuck are you talking about"
and:
"Which fuck are you talking about"

WTF? :yarr


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: VFS on April 26, 2008, 05:20:56 PM
:lol :lol :lol


Title: Re: question for matt
Post by: xoxoch on April 27, 2008, 06:21:20 AM
Plus there is a huge difference between:
"What the fuck are you talking about"
and:
"Which fuck are you talking about"

WTF? :yarr

What "fuck" are you talking about?  :wocka